Hidden in the charming town of Oakland, MD, Brenda's Pizzeria has become a delightful staple for those who relish a hearty taste of New York-style pizza away from the bustling city lights. Located at 21311 Garrett Hwy #2, this inviting pizzeria offers a relaxed spot for family gatherings or casual outings with friends.
Upon stepping inside, the wafting aroma of freshly baked pizza immediately captivates everyone who walks through the doors. The setting, perfect for all ages, exudes a warm and welcoming atmosphere that feels just right whether it’s a solo lunch venture or a family evening out.
The menu here doesn't disappoint. For a start, Brenda's Pizzeria is renowned for its superb New York-style pizza. Crafted with love and precision, each slice is a delectable symphony of flavors — thin crispy crusts topped with rich tomato sauce, gooey cheese that stretches for miles, and a wide selection of fresh toppings that cater to various palates. It's no wonder locals and visitors alike sing high praises about these pies. And it doesn’t just stop at pizza. Brenda’s offers an array of pasta dishes that might make even an Italian grandmother nod in approval. Whether it's the creamy fettuccine Alfredo or a more classic spaghetti and meatballs, these dishes promise satisfaction.
In keeping with modern dietary needs, there are gluten-free options available too, making this pizzeria a considerate choice for those with specific dietary preferences. The gluten-free pizza crusts manage to hold their own, delivering taste without compromise.
As the dishes steadily make their way to the table, a friendly chat with a fellow diner reveals a shared sentiment — Brenda’s is a place that feels like home. She mentions how it has become her go-to spot for reliable meals and how the staff always greet her like an old friend. Between laughter and bites, the communal feel of the place becomes even more apparent.
Located conveniently on Garrett Highway, Brenda's Pizzeria is easy to find yet retains a cozy, intimate charm that draws diners in. Reviews highlight consistent quality, highlighting how this gem never fails to bring joy to the palette. An evening spent here is likely to end with a content sigh, a heartwarming meal enjoyed, and a promise to return soon.
Features & Amenities
From The Business
Identifies as women-owned
Service Options
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery
Highlights
Fast service
Great beer selection
Great dessert
Serves local specialty
Popular For
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining
Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating
Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Coffee
Comfort food
Quick bite
Vegan options
Vegetarian options
Wine
Dining Options
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Seating
Table service
Amenities
Restroom
Wi-Fi
Free Wi-Fi
Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Trendy
Crowd
College students
Family-friendly
Groups
Tourists
Planning
Accepts reservations
Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Kids' menu
Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking
On-site parking
Paid parking lot
Usually plenty of parking
Pets
Dogs allowed outside
Reviews
Average Rating
4.6/5
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 — Plant Worker
The size of the pizza was amazing. The photos do not really show how big the pizzas actually are. We ordered 4 pizzas for 11 people. We could have served 20 people. The taste was also very good and they add ample toppings. It was a really nice treat for a resort area.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 — Pradeep Varadan
If you are hungry and in the mood for a NY style pizza, Brenda's should be your destination. After a day of heavy skiing, we were in a mood to eat a lot! Brenda's is a nice, classic pizzeria in the small town of Deep Creek with the waiting room taking you back through nostalgia of the Yankees. Our waitress was quick, courteous and caring. The pizzas were fresh, delicious and gobsmacking. We even tried a dessert. Go for it!
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 — Sierra Reckley
This is THE BEST PIZZA in the area! I stopped by this week hoping to just grab a few slices. I was happy to find them on the menu. You could smell the garlicky goodness from outside in the parking lot. The staff were helpful and polite. I ordered (1) slice with red sauce and pepperoni and (1) slice of white pizza and added bacon. The slices were huge! I ended up inhaling the red sauce slice first (in the parking lot no less). The crust was cooked perfectly crispy and had a great cheese to sauce ratio. It was so good that I probably didn’t even need to add the pepperoni. I heated up my slice of white pizza at home. It crisped up in the oven amazingly. Brenda’s does white pizza right! I probably didn’t need to add bacon to that either as it was outstanding on its own. You have a new loyal customer!
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 — Joseph Barna
Pizza was very very good, just be prepared to wait. We got a pepperoni, beef stroganoff and chicken bacon ranch pizza. We ordered at 6:11 and pick up was 8:15. I think it was ready in store at 8:35, just for a time reference. Its still a must stop in Deep Creek.
⭐⭐⭐⭐ 4/5 — Leela Roy
Good food. Great tasting Pepperoni pizza. By 5:30pm they are super busy, especially weekends. We ordered 2 pies for take away around 7pm with a pick time of 1hr 20 mins on Saturday evening. But it was worth the wait we picked 15 min beyond the pick up time they were still hot. Highly recommend the pies. But be patient as their wait time can be quite a bit!
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 — Dave “Oink” Mason
They have take out on the First floor and a large dining room on the Second floor with great views. The appetizer (sausage bites) were incredibly delicious. The pizza was fantastic. The dining room is clean and comfortable with lots of room. The service (Gabe) was excellent and super friendly with knowledge of the menu and great suggestions. This is much more than just a pizza place! You should definitely stop by and enjoy some great Italian food.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 — paul charles
We were visiting from out of town for the weekend. This place was absolutely Amazing. Some of the best pizza I have ever had !! Gabe was our server and was absolutely phenomenal. We can't wait to come back!! Keep up the great work.